Why it exists
A disturbance almost always produces some effect, and not all effects are unacceptable. A display flickering for an instant during a discharge may be tolerable; a controller changing the state of an output is not. The performance criterion sets in advance which changes are permissible, so that the result depends on the product’s function and not on the evaluator’s opinion.
How they are usually structured
Immunity standards generally organize the criteria by levels of increasing severity:
- Normal operation: the equipment operates as intended, with no perceptible degradation, during and after the test.
- Temporary degradation with self-recovery: a loss of function or performance is allowed while the disturbance acts, and the equipment returns to its normal state by itself.
- Degradation requiring intervention: the function is lost and needs operator action, such as a restart, to recover.
- Non-recoverable loss: equipment damage or data loss that cannot be corrected, and which is generally not allowed.
The letters or numbers identifying each level and their exact wording depend on the applicable standard, so it should be consulted in its current edition.
How it is defined for a product
The manufacturer, or the product standard, determines the essential functions and what degradation means for each one: a measured value that drifts, a communication link that is interrupted, an indicator that changes state, an alarm that must not trigger. It also decides how they will be monitored during the test, with a reading, an error log or direct observation.
What is seen in practice
Two laboratories can obtain different results with the same equipment if the criterion is not clearly defined. An ambiguous criterion, such as “must work correctly”, leads to arguments. A measurable one, such as “the reading deviation must not exceed a given tolerance and the communication link must not lose frames”, is evaluated without ambiguity.
When it is more demanding
For safety or process control functions, the criterion usually requires continuity without degradation. For office or consumer equipment, it may tolerate brief interruptions with automatic recovery.