The criterion that carries the most weight
The main reason for choosing silicone is fire safety. Its flash and fire points are much higher than those of mineral oil, and its thermal behavior is stable at high operating temperatures. That is why it has been used in transformers indoors or next to buildings.
What changes compared with mineral oil
- Viscosity: silicone is more viscous and its viscosity varies less with temperature; convection cooling is less efficient, and the design must allow for this.
- Cost: normally higher.
- Hygroscopicity and moisture: its behavior toward water differs from that of mineral oil, and moisture tests are interpreted using their own criteria.
- Biodegradability: it is neither of renewable origin nor readily degraded in the environment, so the handling of spills and waste matters.
- Diagnosis: the gases it generates under fault conditions differ from those of mineral oil, and the ratio methods developed for mineral oil do not simply carry over.
What an engineer sees in practice
Equipment filled with silicone cannot be treated with the same machinery or procedures as equipment filled with mineral oil without verifying the compatibility of filters, hoses, and media. Contaminating one fluid with the other alters its properties, so mixing is avoided and each piece of equipment is clearly identified.
How to decide
- Define the fire risk level of the installation and what the applicable regulations require.
- Confirm with the manufacturer that the design accepts the fluid.
- Consider cost, cooling, and maintenance and diagnostic capability.
Handling fluids in power equipment is a matter for qualified personnel, under the applicable safety regulations.