The underlying difference
Ceramics are solids with strong ionic and covalent bonds, with high thermal and chemical stability. Polymers are organic chains with weak bonds between them, easier to mold and more deformable, but with lower tolerance to temperature and to attack by discharges and ultraviolet radiation.
Comparison by criteria
| Criterion | Polymers | Ceramics |
|---|---|---|
| Service temperature | Limited by softening and degradation | Very high in general |
| Mechanical behavior | Tough and flexible | Hard but brittle |
| Forming | Molding and extrusion, complex geometries | Sintering, difficult machining |
| Resistance to arcing and tracking | Variable; many carbonize | Very good, leaves no carbon |
| Weight | Low | Higher |
| Moisture | Some absorb it | Low absorption if well sintered |
On dielectric properties
Neither can be said to be always better. There are polymers with very low dielectric losses at high frequency and ceramics with low losses, but also ceramics with very high permittivity and considerable losses, designed for capacitors. The permittivity of ceramics covers a much wider range, from low to very high values, depending on their composition.
When each is the better choice
- Polymer: housings, wiring, complex molded parts, applications with vibration or impact.
- Ceramic: insulators with high environmental exposure, hot zones, high-frequency and high-power substrates, environments with arcing.
- Composites: polymers with ceramic fillers, which combine ease of processing with better thermal or dielectric behavior.
What the engineer sees in service
A polymer can age, crack or carbonize at the surface. A ceramic fails suddenly from thermal or mechanical shock, sometimes starting at small defects, but it rarely degrades slowly.
When the comparison does not apply
Within each family there is an enormous range of materials. The final decision is made with data for the specific material under real conditions.