What each detector does
- Peak: follows the signal envelope and holds the maximum value during the measurement time. It does not depend on how many times the pulse occurs.
- Quasi-peak: a detector with charge and discharge time constants defined by the standard. An isolated, infrequent pulse discharges between events and produces a low reading; repetitive pulses keep the detector charged and the reading rises. It mimics the annoyance effect of interference on radio reception.
- Average: responds to the mean value of the envelope. It tends to ignore impulsive noise and to highlight continuous carriers.
How they relate
For a given signal, the peak reading is greater than or equal to the quasi-peak reading, and the quasi-peak reading is greater than or equal to the average reading. For an unmodulated continuous carrier, all three are practically equal. For low-repetition impulsive noise, peak is much higher than average.
How they are combined in practice
- A fast sweep is made with the peak detector, because it is the fastest and most conservative.
- If the peak is below both the quasi-peak and the average limit, the equipment complies and there is no need to continue.
- If the peak exceeds either limit, only those frequencies are remeasured, with the detector the limit requires.
- Each result is compared with the limit for the same detector.
How to interpret the results
Comparing a peak reading with an average limit can suggest a noncompliance that does not exist; it is the most pessimistic reading. Conversely, comparing an average reading with a quasi-peak limit would give an overly optimistic conclusion. Each limit is defined for a specific detector.
Equipment with continuous, narrowband noise, such as a clock or a switching power supply, shows almost the same reading on all three, so the chosen detector changes the result very little. Equipment with a brushed motor generates irregular bursts, and the difference between detectors can be large.