What is really being decided
Reclamation recovers the existing oil by removing the oxidation products. Replacement substitutes the volume with new oil. The question is not which is better in general, but what condition the oil and equipment are in, and whether the treatment corrects the cause.
When reclamation is favored
- Degradation is progressive and sludge has not yet deposited on the windings.
- Acidity and interfacial tension indicate oxidation, but the oil has no other problematic contaminants.
- The paper shows a reasonable condition (for example, based on furans and gases).
- The aim is to keep the oil and reduce waste and logistics.
When replacement is favored
- Contamination with substances that the adsorbent does not remove or that cannot be verified.
- Oil with properties that treatment cannot restore.
- A need to change the type of fluid.
- When reclamation would demand more cycles than replacing the oil.
What neither one solves
Neither reclamation nor replacement repairs aged paper or completely removes sludge already adhered to the active parts. If the equipment has deposits or the solid insulation is at the end of its life, changing the oil adds little to the service life.
What an engineer sees in practice
Results for acidity, interfacial tension, color, inhibitor, moisture, particles, gases, and furans are gathered, and the history of the equipment is considered. If the oil is at an early stage of oxidation, treatment is effective. Beyond a certain stage, the improvement is partial and the effect lasts less time.
An example of the reasoning
A transformer with dark oil and low interfacial tension, no fault gases, and acceptable paper is a clear candidate for reclamation. If it also shows deposits on inspection, internal flushing is added. All work is done with the equipment de-energized and by qualified personnel.