An instrument conforms when its error is within the permitted limit, but the measured error has uncertainty. If the result falls very close to the limit, it cannot be stated with certainty on which side the true value lies. This is why a decision rule must be agreed before calibrating: a procedure that specifies how to use uncertainty to state conformity.
The decision zones
Three zones form around the limit. Inside, far from the limit, conformity is clear. Outside, far from the limit, nonconformity is clear. Between the two, in a band on the order of the uncertainty, the result is ambiguous and the rule must say what to do.
Common rules
- Simple acceptance: the measured result is compared with the limit without considering uncertainty. It is simple, but it carries risk when the result is close to the limit.
- Guard band for acceptance: the acceptance zone is narrowed by subtracting an amount tied to the uncertainty. This reduces the risk of accepting an instrument that is actually out of tolerance.
- Guard band for rejection: rejection occurs only if the result exceeds the limit by more than the uncertainty. This reduces the risk of rejecting something good.
Risks being controlled
There are two types of wrong decision: false acceptance, which misleadingly benefits the user, and false rejection, which generates unnecessary costs. The decision rule chooses how to divide those risks according to the consequences. In safety-critical applications, protection against false acceptance is preferred.
An example
An instrument shows an error close to the permitted limit. With simple acceptance it is declared conforming; with a guard band for acceptance, it is declared nonconforming or a larger margin is requested. The same measurement produces different decisions, which is why the rule must be defined and agreed in advance, and written into the contract or procedure.
When it is not needed
If the uncertainty is very small compared with the tolerance, the difference between rules is negligible and simple acceptance may be sufficient.