What changes with electrode shape
The breakdown voltage of a liquid depends on the field in the zone between electrodes and on the volume of liquid subjected to a high field. Flat electrodes have a central zone of fairly uniform field, though with intensification at the edges. Electrodes with a spherical or rounded profile generate a non-uniform field concentrated in the zone of closest approach. This changes the volume of oil under the highest stress and, with it, the probability of encountering a contaminant that initiates the discharge.
Comparison
| Aspect | Flat electrodes | Spherical or rounded electrodes |
|---|---|---|
| Field between electrodes | More uniform at the center, with edge effect | Less uniform, more intense in the zone of closest approach |
| Sensitivity to water and particles | Lower | Higher, discriminates better between clean and dirty oils |
| Typical use | Quick check of an in-service oil | Finer evaluation of cleanliness and of treated oil |
| Stirring | Usually omitted in some methods | Some methods include it to homogenize |
The gaps, rates of voltage rise and acceptance criteria differ in each standardized method, so it is advisable to consult the current edition of the relevant standard.
What this means for the results
- Values obtained with one configuration are not directly comparable with those of the other, nor are the acceptance criteria.
- A less sensitive test may pass an oil that another would reject, and this is not an error but a consequence of the geometry.
- For a treated oil with little contamination, the more sensitive configuration is more informative.
What to check first
- Which method the specification or contract calls for.
- That the gap and the condition of the electrodes, free of pitting and residues, are those of the method.
- That the cell is rinsed with the sample itself and that the sample rests for the indicated time before voltage is applied.
When comparison does not apply
The trend of a unit must not be followed by mixing results from the two setups. If the method is changed, it is advisable to repeat a sample with both to establish a new baseline.