Two different principles
An electronic regulator measures the output voltage and, if it deviates, changes the transformation ratio: it switches autotransformer taps with relays or semiconductors, or adjusts continuously with a servomotor. A constant-voltage transformer (CVT) is ferroresonant: it has a core section that operates saturated, coupled to a resonant capacitor, so the output voltage hardly varies when the input voltage changes.
What each one corrects
- Electronic regulator: corrects sustained low or high voltage with a response on the order of a few cycles, depending on the design. Regulation is done in steps, and tap changes may appear as small discontinuities. It does not eliminate noise or high-frequency transients by itself, and it provides no galvanic isolation if it is an autotransformer.
- CVT: stabilizes the voltage with no moving parts or switching, isolates from the input through its transformer and attenuates noise and transients. The energy stored in the resonant circuit allows it to ride through very brief sags.
CVT limitations
Its output usually has a distorted waveform with more harmonic content, and it is sensitive to input frequency. It works best with a load close to its rated value: at light load its regulation worsens, and under overload the output voltage can collapse. The inrush current of certain loads and nonlinear loads are also problematic. It generates heat and audible noise, and it is heavy and bulky.
Electronic regulator limitations
It offers no backup against deep sags or interruptions. Its response takes cycles and is not immediate. With loads that have high inrush currents, the voltage can drop before the regulator corrects it.
What neither one does
Neither replaces a battery backup system: neither the regulator nor the CVT sustains the load during an interruption or a deep sag.
How to choose
If the problem is sustained low or high voltage and the load is varied, an electronic regulator is the usual choice. If there is noise, disturbance and small, steady loads that need a very stable voltage, the CVT is an option. Before choosing, measure what type of disturbance is present: regulation for slow variations does not cure a problem of brief sags or transients. Installation is work for qualified personnel.