The underlying difference
Both transformers do the same thing electrically. What changes is the medium that insulates and removes heat. In a dry-type unit, air and solid materials such as resin or varnish perform both functions. In an immersed unit, the oil insulates and carries heat from the windings to the walls and radiators.
Comparison
| Aspect | Dry-type | Oil-immersed |
|---|---|---|
| Cooling | Air; less effective | Oil; very effective |
| Power and voltage range | More limited | Covers distribution through power classes |
| Fire risk | Low; no combustible oil | Higher, except with high-flash-point fluids and containment measures |
| Installation | Indoors, close to the load | Indoors with safeguards, or outdoors with a pit |
| Sensitivity to the environment | Dust, moisture and pollution affect the insulation | Closed tank protects the windings |
| Diagnostics | Inspection, thermography, partial discharge | Oil analysis and dissolved gases, in addition to electrical tests |
What weighs in the decision
- Location: in buildings, hospitals or places with many people, a dry-type unit avoids oil and simplifies protection requirements.
- Capacity: for large ratings and high voltages, oil is almost mandatory because of its ability to cool and insulate.
- Environment: in dusty or humid atmospheres, a dry-type unit needs additional cleaning and protection.
- Maintenance: oil offers a rich source of diagnostic information but demands sampling and leak control; a dry-type unit requires fewer interventions, but its internal faults are harder to anticipate.
When a direct comparison does not apply
There are high-flash-point fluids, such as esters, that bring immersed units closer to applications once reserved for dry-type units. There are also cast-resin and vacuum pressure impregnated dry-type units, which behave differently with respect to moisture and overload. The choice must start from the installation requirements and the applicable safety regulations, not from a general rule.