Two media with very different affinities
Cellulose paper and pressboard are hygroscopic: they retain water with much greater affinity than mineral oil, which dissolves only small amounts. For that reason, in a transformer with wet solid insulation, almost all the water in the system is in the paper even if the oil appears dry.
Equilibrium and temperature
A dynamic equilibrium exists between the oil and the paper. At higher temperature, the oil can dissolve more water and the paper tends to release part of its own into the oil. On cooling, the oil loses dissolving capacity and the water returns to the paper. The water concentration in the oil is therefore not constant: it rises and falls with the temperature of the equipment even if the total amount of water does not change.
The equilibrium is described with equilibrium curves or isotherms, which relate the water content of the paper to the moisture of the oil at a given temperature. These curves are empirical and depend on the type of oil and paper, so their results are estimates.
The process is slow
Water migrates by diffusion, especially through the thickness of the paper, and this takes anywhere from hours to weeks or months, depending on temperature and thickness. In a loaded transformer with changing temperatures, perfect equilibrium is rarely reached. A sample taken after a sudden load change may not reflect the long-term distribution.
What this means for measurement
- A water-in-oil reading must be accompanied by the oil temperature at the time of sampling.
- A sample taken cold underestimates the moisture that will be present when the equipment is running hot.
- To estimate the moisture in the paper, use the relative saturation of the oil, which is less sensitive to temperature than the concentration in parts per million.
What an engineer sees in practice
If a hot oil sample gives moderate moisture, but the equipment has a history of wet solid insulation, there may be a significant reservoir in the paper. Drying only the oil without treating the paper produces a temporary decrease, because the paper gives up water again. Water in the paper accelerates the aging of the cellulose and, at high temperatures, can be released as bubbles, so its evolution should be monitored.