What changes between the two
Both protect against the thermal radiation and fragments of an electric arc. The main difference is coverage. The face shield is a visor that covers the face and attaches to a hard hat or headgear; on its own it leaves the neck and the back of the neck exposed, so it is supplemented with a balaclava or another arc-rated item. The full hood is a garment that wraps around the head and neck, with a transparent front window, and it is worn with the hard hat underneath or integrated, depending on the design.
Comparison criteria
| Aspect | Face shield | Full hood |
|---|---|---|
| Coverage | Face and forehead; the neck depends on the balaclava | Head, neck and face together |
| Comfort | Lighter and better ventilated | More heat and restricted movement |
| Visibility | Wide shield, easy to lift | Limited window, with less side vision |
| Typical use | Tasks with moderate incident energy | Tasks with high incident energy |
| Maintenance | Replaceable shield and support | Washable garment with interchangeable window |
How to decide
- Take the incident energy from the arc flash study and the protection category required for the task.
- Choose equipment whose tested rating equals or exceeds that value.
- Ensure compatibility with the hard hat, glasses and other items.
- Consider the duration of the task, the ambient heat and the need for communication.
A practical detail
A face shield that is displaced by the impact or that leaves the neck uncovered significantly reduces the real protection. That is why the complete system is evaluated as a whole, not item by item. At high energy levels, a full hood is the most common solution, often combined with a ventilation system to make the heat tolerable.
Work involving an arc flash hazard must be carried out by qualified personnel following the applicable regulations.