First the path, then the tool
All interference has a source, a coupling path and a receiver. The three techniques act on the path. A poor choice costs weight, money and time, so it pays to identify where the disturbance passes before adding components.
| Technique | Coupling it addresses | Limitation |
|---|---|---|
| Shielding | Radiated fields between the equipment and the outside; field coupling between modules | Apertures and the cables passing through it defeat it |
| Filtering | Disturbances conducted along power and signal cables | Does not stop what couples through the field; needs a good ground |
| Separation and layout | Capacitive and inductive coupling between nearby traces, cables and modules | Requires space; does not work for very strong sources |
How to recognize the path
- If the emission changes when a cable is moved or disconnected, the problem travels along the cable: filtering or a ferrite.
- If the emission remains with all cables disconnected and changes when covers are closed or opened, the enclosure is part of the path: shielding and joints.
- If the effect depends on the distance between two cables or modules and decreases as they are moved apart, the coupling is local capacitive or inductive coupling: separation, orientation or perpendicular crossing.
Why they complement each other
A perfect shield with an unfiltered cable is of no use: the cable conducts the disturbance to the outside and acts as an antenna. An excellent filter in an enclosure with open seams does not help with a source radiating inside either. In practice, the solution is usually a combination in which each technique works where it belongs, together with good grounding.
And before any of them
Reducing the source is usually more economical: slower edges, smaller loops, less clock activity. Addressing the source lowers the demand on everything else.