How they are built
Paper-oil cable has paper tapes wound over the conductor and impregnated with oil or compound, inside a metallic sheath, normally lead, that keeps it sealed. Extruded cable has a continuous polymer layer, such as cross-linked polyethylene or ethylene propylene rubber, applied together with inner and outer semiconducting shields.
How they age and fail
- Paper-oil: suffers from moisture entering through sheath damage, from oil migration on routes with changes in elevation and from thermal degradation of the cellulose. An oil leak is an obvious warning.
- Extruded: suffers from water and electrical treeing, from voids and contaminants that produce partial discharges and from damage at the interfaces with the shields.
Practical differences
- Installation and accessories: extruded cable is lighter and more flexible, and its prefabricated joints and terminations are simpler. Paper cable requires careful joints that protect the paper from moisture.
- Maintenance: paper-oil may require pressure and oil monitoring in some designs; extruded cable requires almost none.
- Diagnostics: the acceptable test methods differ; for example, DC has historically been accepted on paper, while other techniques are preferred on extruded cable.
- Overload tolerance: this depends on the design and the material, and the manufacturer’s specification governs.
When to use one or the other
In new installations extruded cable predominates because of its ease of installation and maintenance. Paper-oil remains in service in older networks, where it must be evaluated with methods specific to its technology.
How to interpret a test result
A dissipation factor or resistance value is not interpreted in the same way for both: the acceptance criteria and failure causes are different, so the criteria for one type are not applied to the other.
These activities involve hazardous voltages: they must be carried out by qualified, authorized personnel, following the applicable regulations and the facility’s lockout and grounding procedures.