24/7 emergencies 814 777 6921812 230 6079WhatsApp 811 786 0768
Electrónica MonterreyElectrónica MonterreyLaboratorios Creativeit Talk to an engineer
Menu

Why do two analyzers report different harmonics in the same installation?

Two analyzers can report different harmonics in the same installation because of differences in connection point, synchronization, calculation window, component grouping, averaging interval, accuracy class or sensors, or even because the load changed between measurements.

First, was the same thing measured?

Many differences are due to conditions and not to the quality of the instrument. A different point on the circuit, an inverted phase, a load operating at another level or at another time, or time windows that do not match are enough to produce different and legitimate results.

Differences in calculation method

  • Window and synchronization: the Fourier transform requires a window with a whole number of cycles. If the instrument does not track the network frequency well, spectral leakage appears.
  • Grouping: some report individual lines and others harmonic groups or subgroups that include neighboring components, which changes the value when interharmonics are present.
  • Aggregation interval and statistic: an instantaneous maximum, an average over several minutes and a high percentile are not comparable.
  • Percentage base: percentage of the fundamental, of nominal or of demand (for current, THD and TDD are different).

Hardware differences

  • Performance class: an instrument designed to the strictest measurement requirements is expected to be more repeatable than a general-purpose one.
  • Current sensors: bandwidth, linearity at low current, phase shift and inherent noise.
  • Noise floor and resolution: these matter for low-level harmonics.
  • Anti-aliasing filters and sampling frequency, which limit the highest order measured faithfully.

What to check first

  1. That both measure at the same point, with the same transformation ratios and polarity.
  2. That the recording period and time are synchronized.
  3. That the aggregation, statistic and percentage base settings are identical.
  4. That the current sensors have comparable characteristics.
  5. If they still differ, measure with both on the same signal from a reference source.

How to interpret the result

Small differences in low-value orders are normal. A large difference in a dominant harmonic usually reveals a configuration, scale or sensor error. Before attributing the discrepancy to one of the instruments, both configurations are documented and the differences in method are corrected.

We do real tests, on video! Watch them on our YouTube channel →

Do you have a problem nobody has been able to measure?

Talk directly to the engineer in charge, with no middlemen.

Talk to an engineer