24/7 emergencies 814 777 6921812 230 6079WhatsApp 811 786 0768
Electrónica MonterreyElectrónica MonterreyLaboratorios Creativeit Talk to an engineer
Menu

Why does the same oil sample give different results between laboratories?

The same oil sample gives different results between laboratories, in most cases, because the sample changed between one analysis and the other (water, gases, particles) or because the test methods and conditions are not identical. The uncertainty inherent in the method explains the rest.

First, is it the same sample?

Oil is a living system in the container. It absorbs moisture from the air if the container is not perfectly sealed, loses dissolved gases, deposits particles and free water at the bottom, and changes with temperature and light. If a sample is split into two containers or sent to one laboratory days after the other, the same material is no longer being compared. That is why the most frequent cause of discrepancy occurs before the oil reaches the instrument.

Causes by stage

  • Sampling: different sampling point, insufficient purging of the valve, poorly rinsed container, exposure to air, different oil temperature.
  • Container and transport: syringes, bottles or cylinders with different materials and closures; transit time; impacts and temperature variations that displace water and gases.
  • Preparation: whether or not the sample is homogenized before weighing or injecting; letting bubbles settle; whether or not it is filtered.
  • Method and equipment: the same quantity can be measured by different methods, with different electrodes, cells, test temperatures or times; each gives its own value.
  • Test conditions: cell temperature, ambient humidity, cleanliness of the equipment and calibration.
  • Uncertainty and repeatability: each method has an inherent spread. Breakdown tests and water tests at low concentrations are especially scattered.

What an engineer sees in practice

Two reports with different values, both within the acceptance criteria, are often explained by uncertainty. When one passes and the other fails, compare the methods cited, the test temperatures, the analysis dates and the condition of the containers received.

How to reduce the discrepancy

  1. Take the sample in a single operation, at one point, and split it into equivalent containers.
  2. Record the temperature, time and conditions of sampling.
  3. Send to both laboratories with similar lead times, protected from light and air.
  4. Ask that both reports state the method, test temperature and uncertainty.
  5. If the difference persists, repeat with a new sample and, if justified, with a common reference sample.

How to interpret the result

Before questioning a laboratory, verify that the conditions are comparable. A difference that is small relative to the uncertainty is not a contradiction; a large, reproducible difference signals a method, sample or calibration problem that must be investigated.

We do real tests, on video! Watch them on our YouTube channel →

Do you have a problem nobody has been able to measure?

Talk directly to the engineer in charge, with no middlemen.

Talk to an engineer