24/7 emergencies 814 777 6921812 230 6079WhatsApp 811 786 0768
Electrónica MonterreyElectrónica MonterreyLaboratorios Creativeit Talk to an engineer
Menu

Why does a residual current device not protect against all contact?

A residual current device detects current that leaks to ground, not just any contact: it does not protect if the current returns through the neutral, if contact is between two live conductors, or against leakage below its threshold.

What a residual current device measures

The device compares the current going in with the current coming out through the live conductors. A difference means that part of the current has taken another path, normally ground, and if it exceeds the threshold the device trips. Everything it can do, and all its limits, stem from that principle.

Situations the device does not detect

  • Contact between phase and neutral: if a person touches both conductors of the same circuit, current passes through the body and returns through the neutral; the device sees that what goes in equals what comes out and does not trip.
  • Contact between two phases: the same case; current flows between live conductors without passing through ground.
  • Leakage below the threshold: a current lower than its sensitivity does not activate the device, even though it may be felt.
  • Operating time: the device opens in a short time, but not instantly; during that interval current passes through the person.
  • Overcurrents and short circuits: a pure residual current device does not protect against them; it needs associated protection.
  • Special waveforms: certain device types do not detect leakage with a direct current or high-frequency component produced by electronic equipment; there are types designed for this.

Failures of the device itself

  1. A stuck mechanism or a degraded component may not trip, which is why there is a test button.
  2. A neutral connected to ground downstream of the device can cause nuisance tripping or inhibit detection.
  3. An installation without a protective conductor limits the faults that divert to ground.

What is seen in the field

A person who touches phase and neutral with their hands can receive a severe shock even with a residual current device installed and in good condition. That is why this device is complementary protection, not a substitute for the others: grounding, insulation, good practices, de-energizing before working.

How to interpret the protection

The device reduces one type of risk: current diverted to ground. The other risks require other measures. Testing the device and measuring leakage are part of maintenance.

Work on these installations must be done by qualified personnel, following the applicable regulations.

We do real tests, on video! Watch them on our YouTube channel →

Do you have a problem nobody has been able to measure?

Talk directly to the engineer in charge, with no middlemen.

Talk to an engineer