The idea
In an installation with breakers in series, from the main breaker to the final circuits, a fault on a final circuit must cause its own breaker to open and not the main one. That condition is selectivity. It is the result sought when coordinating protections: device curves are set and chosen so that their operating zones do not overlap.
Total and partial selectivity
Selectivity is total if it holds for any fault current up to the maximum possible at the point. It is partial if it holds only up to a certain current value; above that value, both breakers may open. Manufacturers publish tables showing up to what current selectivity is guaranteed between specific combinations of their equipment, and those data are applied rather than assumed.
How it is achieved
- By current: the upstream breaker has an instantaneous threshold higher than the maximum current the downstream breaker can see. It works when there is a lot of impedance between the two.
- By time: the upstream breaker waits for a delay to give the downstream breaker a chance to act. This requires the breaker to withstand the fault current during that delay, and it increases the fault energy.
- By energy: this takes advantage of the current limitation of molded-case circuit breakers and their behavior during tripping.
- By zones: electronic trip units communicate with each other; the one that detects the fault notifies the one above so that it does not delay, or orders it to wait. This allows selectivity with short clearing times.
What is seen in practice
If selectivity fails, a short circuit in one machine leaves an entire production line or building without power. The cause is usually an instantaneous setting that is too low, breakers unable to withstand the delay, or combinations of equipment from different families without selectivity data.
Considerations
Total selectivity can make the installation more expensive, because it requires breakers of higher capacity or with more sophisticated trip units, and it can conflict with reducing arc energy. It is evaluated together with the short-circuit study. Trip tests and settings are done by qualified personnel.