24/7 emergencies 814 777 6921812 230 6079WhatsApp 811 786 0768
Electrónica MonterreyElectrónica MonterreyLaboratorios Creativeit Talk to an engineer
Menu

Phase or Amplitude Modulation: What Is the Trade-Off?

Modulating phase is more robust against amplitude noise and keeps power constant, while adding amplitude allows more bits per symbol to be transmitted, at the cost of requiring greater linearity and a better signal-to-noise ratio.

The trade-off in one sentence

With phase alone, the constellation states are spread around a circle of fixed radius. With phase and amplitude, they are spread over several circles or a grid. This changes how many bits are sent per symbol, how far apart the points are and what is demanded of the transmitter.

Phase modulation

  • Amplitude is constant, so the power amplifier can work close to saturation without distorting the information, with good energy efficiency.
  • It withstands noise and channel amplitude variations well, because the information is not in the amplitude.
  • As the number of phases increases, the points move closer together on the circle. The spacing between neighbors shrinks quickly, and a higher signal-to-noise ratio and an oscillator with low phase jitter are needed.

Combined amplitude and phase modulation

  • By using several amplitude levels in addition to phase, more points can be accommodated with a greater minimum spacing than if they were all on a single circle, which improves spectral efficiency.
  • The signal envelope varies, so the amplifier must be linear. If it compresses, the outer points flatten and errors and leakage into neighboring channels increase.
  • It is more sensitive to channel gain variations, so the receiver needs more careful gain control and channel estimation.

How to decide

Situation What tends to suit it
Weak or noisy link, or low-power equipment where efficiency is critical Pure phase, few states
Link with a good signal-to-noise ratio and a need for high speed Amplitude and phase, many states
Channel that varies over time Scheme that adapts to the state of the link

That is why current systems negotiate the scheme dynamically: they use the densest one while the signal-to-noise ratio allows it and drop to a robust one when it worsens.

How it looks in practice

On a vector analyzer, a dense scheme with an amplifier at its limit shows compressed outer points. Backing off the power or linearizing recovers them.

We do real tests, on video! Watch them on our YouTube channel →

Do you have a problem nobody has been able to measure?

Talk directly to the engineer in charge, with no middlemen.

Talk to an engineer