What each one measures
A personal detector is worn on the body, close to the breathing zone, and records what that person breathes as they move around. An area detector is placed at a location in the space or around it and measures the conditions at that point, sometimes transmitting readings to the outside.
Comparison
| Aspect | Personal | Area |
|---|---|---|
| What it represents | The person’s exposure | The condition at one point in the space |
| Mobility | Goes with the worker | Fixed or relocatable |
| Strength | Alarms where the person is | Can be monitored from outside and can detect changes before they reach the entrants |
| Limitation | Only sees its immediate surroundings | Does not reflect each person’s breathing zone |
| Typical use | Each entrant | Critical points, the entrance, the ventilation discharge |
How they complement each other
An area detector in the low part of the space can warn of a heavy gas building up before it reaches breathing level. But if the worker moves to a different zone, the area detector is of no use to them. The personal detector follows the person, but it only warns when the gas reaches their body. With both, you have a view of the space and an individual alarm.
Decision criteria
- Each person who enters carries their own personal detector. Sharing one among several people does not protect them all.
- Area detectors are added when the space is large or has several levels, when work generates contaminants, or when monitoring from outside is needed.
- An area detector outside monitors the fan discharge and the entrance, because gases from the surroundings can get in there.
When one alone is not enough
With an area detector only, people are unprotected beyond its reach. With a personal detector only, the attendant outside does not know what is happening inside until someone reacts. Neither one replaces pre-entry measurement or the rescue plan.
Common requirements
Both require a functional test before use, periodic calibration and active alarms. A poorly placed area detector can give a false sense of security, for example one placed at the entrance that cannot see what is happening at the bottom. Selection and use are the responsibility of trained personnel, in accordance with the applicable regulations.
This guide is for information only. Work involving electrical hazards, heights or hazardous atmospheres must be carried out by qualified, authorized personnel, following the applicable regulations.