What differs between them
Both change the number of turns in service to adjust the transformation ratio. The difference is when they can be operated. The off-load tap changer (DETC) requires the transformer to be disconnected, because its contacts are not designed to interrupt current. The on-load tap changer (OLTC) incorporates a diverter switch with transition resistors or reactors and can change taps while load current flows.
Comparison
| Aspect | Off-load | On-load |
|---|---|---|
| Operation | With the equipment de-energized | In service, manual or automatic |
| Typical use | Seasonal or installation adjustment | Continuous voltage regulation |
| Complexity | Low | High: selector, diverter switch, motor drive |
| Maintenance | Operate occasionally to clean the contacts | Scheduled by operation count and compartment oil analysis |
| Cost | Lower | Higher |
How to decide
- If the grid voltage varies little and adjustment is rarely needed, an off-load unit is sufficient.
- If the secondary-side voltage must be held within bands under varying loads, an on-load unit is what makes this possible.
- If an interruption to change taps is not acceptable, only an on-load unit will do.
Details that matter
- Taps are usually located on the winding with the lower current, generally the high-voltage winding, so that the contacts handle less current. One consequence is that the adjustment also changes the flux and the impedance of the unit.
- In an off-load tap changer that has not been operated for years, the contacts can build up a film and their resistance can rise. Moving it through its full travel, with the equipment de-energized, helps clean them.
- The on-load tap changer has moving parts and arcing at every operation. It is one of the transformer components that requires the most maintenance attention.
The tap changer position must be recorded and compared with the position used in the transformation ratio tests, so that the results can be interpreted.
Warning: operating or working on tap changers involves electrical risk. It must be done by qualified personnel, following the applicable regulations and lockout/tagout procedures.