24/7 emergencies 814 777 6921812 230 6079WhatsApp 811 786 0768
Electrónica MonterreyElectrónica MonterreyLaboratorios Creativeit Talk to an engineer
Menu

Microwave Link or Fiber Optics?

Fiber optics offers greater capacity, lower and stable latency and immunity to electromagnetic interference, but requires conduit; a microwave link deploys faster and clears obstacles without civil works, but depends on line of sight and weather.

The nature of each medium

Fiber guides light inside a dielectric conductor, isolated from the environment. Microwave propagates a wave through free space between antennas, and shares the medium with other signals and with the atmosphere. Almost all the advantages and disadvantages arise from this difference.

Comparison

Aspect Fiber optics Microwave
Capacity Very high and expandable with terminal equipment Limited by the assigned bandwidth
Electromagnetic interference Immune, being dielectric Susceptible to other signals
Effect of weather None on transmission Rain and other phenomena attenuate, especially at high frequencies
Line of sight Not required Essential, with a clear Fresnel zone
Deployment Civil works, rights-of-way permits, cable laying Antenna installation, sometimes spectrum paperwork
Electrical isolation Galvanically isolates both ends Also isolates, with no physical conductor
Physical security Tapping it requires access to the cable The signal propagates through the air

What decides in practice

  • Future capacity required: if large growth is expected, fiber leaves more headroom without changing the medium.
  • Terrain and rights of way: a river, a railway or someone else’s land can make cable laying unfeasible or very slow, and that is where microwave wins.
  • Required availability: a microwave link is designed with a fade margin. Even so, it will have more variability than fiber.
  • Electromagnetic environment: in substations or plants with large fields and strong transients, fiber avoids ground loops and poor isolation.
  • Time frame and duration of use: for temporary or backup links, microwave is more agile.

A common approach

Many systems combine both: fiber as the main link and microwave as a backup on an independent physical route, so that a cable cut does not leave the site cut off.

We do real tests, on video! Watch them on our YouTube channel →

Do you have a problem nobody has been able to measure?

Talk directly to the engineer in charge, with no middlemen.

Talk to an engineer