24/7 emergencies 814 777 6921812 230 6079WhatsApp 811 786 0768
Electrónica MonterreyElectrónica MonterreyLaboratorios Creativeit Talk to an engineer
Menu

How is reactive power measured in unbalanced loads?

Reactive power in unbalanced loads is measured per phase, using the voltage and current of each phase, and then summed. The delicate part is that under unbalance, total apparent power and total power factor have several definitions that are not equivalent.

Measure per phase

With a balanced load it is enough to measure one phase and multiply by three. With an unbalanced load it is not: each phase has its own active power, reactive power and power factor. The correct procedure is to measure voltage and current in each phase and calculate the power per phase from the same simultaneous sampling. Total active power and total fundamental reactive power are the algebraic sum of the three phases, and one phase may have inductive reactive power while another has capacitive reactive power.

Connection methods

  • Three-element (three wattmeters): used in four-wire systems with a neutral. It measures each phase with respect to neutral and is valid for any degree of unbalance.
  • Two-element (Aron connection): in three-wire systems with no neutral, two correctly connected wattmeters give the total active power. Total reactive power can also be obtained, but not the reactive power of each phase.

The apparent power problem

Under unbalance, total apparent power does not have a single definition. It can be calculated as the arithmetic sum of the per-phase apparent powers, as the magnitude of the vector sum, or as an effective apparent power that uses equivalent RMS values of the three phases, the approach found in the IEEE 1459 recommended practice. Each gives a different total power factor. So when comparing results, you need to know which definition the instrument uses and what the evaluation criterion requires.

What an engineer sees in practice

The power factor of one phase turns out to be very different from that of another, or the total depends on how the meter calculates it. Compensation calculated from the average can overcompensate one phase and leave another short. If the load is highly unbalanced, it is also advisable to analyze the negative sequence.

How to interpret the result

Symmetrical three-phase capacitors compensate all three phases equally, so they do not resolve the unbalance. If phases need to be corrected separately, per-phase compensation equipment or load balancing should be considered. Measurements in energized panels are work for qualified personnel.

We do real tests, on video! Watch them on our YouTube channel →

Do you have a problem nobody has been able to measure?

Talk directly to the engineer in charge, with no middlemen.

Talk to an engineer