What the loss tangent quantifies
It is the ratio between the dissipative part and the stored part of the dielectric response of the material. In a printed circuit it translates into signal attenuation: the higher the loss tangent, the more energy is converted into heat inside the substrate. Its values are small in good high-frequency substrates, and that smallness is what makes it hard to measure.
Why resonant methods are preferred
A resonator loaded with the sample has a quality factor that degrades in proportion to the losses of the material. Measuring a change in quality factor is far more sensitive than measuring a small attenuation in simple transmission. Cavity, split-plane (split-post) and ring-line resonators are used for that reason, although they measure at one or several discrete frequencies.
Broadband methods
Printed transmission lines, such as microstrip or coplanar lines, make it possible to extract the effective permittivity and the attenuation across a band. The difficulty is separating dielectric losses from conductor and radiation losses. Achieving this requires modeling the copper roughness and comparing lines of different lengths.
Complications specific to substrates
- Anisotropy: woven-reinforced laminates have different properties in the plane and through the thickness. Each method measures a different field orientation.
- Copper roughness: increases conductor losses and can be mistaken for dielectric losses.
- Moisture: raises losses, so prior conditioning is mandatory.
- Frequency: the value depends on it, so it must always be reported with the measurement frequency and temperature.
What the engineer sees
Two methods can give somewhat different values for the same laminate because they excite different field orientations, work at a different frequency or include other effects. This is not an error in itself: the choice must match how the substrate will be used in the design.
How to interpret the result
Use it as input data for insertion loss simulation, verifying that the frequency and orientation of the measurement resemble those of the application.