Why measuring the oil is not enough
The temperature that limits insulation life is that of the hottest spot in the winding, which is higher than the oil temperature and higher than the average conductor temperature. It cannot be reached with an ordinary thermometer, because it lies inside the winding, on a live conductor. That is why direct or indirect methods are used.
Direct measurement
Fiber optic probes are placed in the windings during manufacture, in the areas where the hot spot is expected. The fiber is a dielectric and can be used without compromising the insulation or picking up electrical interference. It is the most faithful measurement, but it must be planned from the design stage and cannot be added once the unit has been built.
Thermal image
This is the most widespread indirect method. An indicator takes the top oil temperature and adds an increment that emulates the heating of the winding relative to the oil. That increment is obtained by feeding a heating element with a current proportional to the load current, taken from a current transformer. The calibration is adjusted with the data from the transformer’s heat run test. Today this is also done with numerical models in electronic devices, which use the load, the oil temperature and the ambient temperature.
Resistance method
Because the resistance of a conductor varies with temperature in a known way, comparing the cold resistance with the resistance measured immediately after the load is disconnected gives the average winding temperature. This is used in factory heat run tests, and it yields an average value, not the hot spot.
Limitations
- Indirect methods depend on calibration and design parameters; if the cooling or the load changes, they can drift.
- Thermal inertia makes the winding respond faster than the oil, and indicators must take this into account.
- The hot spot can vary with the tap changer position and the cooling conditions.
What the engineer sees
Indicators with alarms and trips, trend records checked against load and ambient conditions, and control of fans and pumps based on winding temperature. A discrepancy between the indicated temperature and the one expected for the load reveals cooling or calibration problems. Calibration and adjustments are carried out by qualified personnel.