The definition and the trap
Efficiency is η = Pout / Pin, but using active power, not volt-amperes. Measuring with a current clamp and a voltmeter and multiplying gives apparent power, which overestimates the input and underestimates the efficiency. That is why a power analyzer is used that calculates the true active power, including distortion.
How the measurement is set up
- At the AC input, an analyzer measures the voltage and current of each phase and calculates the total power.
- At the DC output, the voltage and current delivered by the charger are measured, with an electronic load or a battery as the destination.
- Both measurements are taken in the same time window, ideally with energy integration to reduce the effect of variations.
What determines the result
The losses of a charger are switching, conduction, magnetics, cooling and self-consumption. The last two weigh more when the delivered power is low, so on the efficiency-versus-load curve efficiency is lower at low loads, rises to a maximum in the mid-range and may drop slightly at full load. That is why an efficiency figure without its operating point does not say much.
Points worth measuring
Several power and output voltage levels are covered, because the vehicle voltage changes with its state of charge. Measurements are taken with the equipment already at a stable temperature, since the resistance of the semiconductors changes as they heat up. Standby consumption is also added, which affects the total energy even though it does not appear at the full-load point.
Uncertainty
Because efficiency is a ratio of two measurements, the error of each one adds up. At high efficiencies the difference between input and output is small, so a modest error in the current sensors translates into a relatively large uncertainty in the losses. It is advisable to use calibrated sensors with adequate accuracy.
Measurements on energized chargers are the responsibility of qualified personnel and are subject to the applicable electrical safety regulations.