Both are buried conductor configurations, but they distribute current and potential differently.
Perimeter ring
This is a closed conductor surrounding the area of an installation or building. It reduces resistance by enlarging the area covered and, in buildings, serves as the base for connecting lightning down conductors and structures. Its advantages are simplicity and moderate cost.
Its limitation is that the interior is left without conductors. The surface potential inside the ring can bulge relative to the edge when current flows, and a person touching a connected structure within that zone can be subjected to a high touch voltage if the current is large.
Grid
This is a lattice of interconnected horizontal conductors, normally combined with a perimeter conductor and sometimes with rods. Because there are conductors in the interior, the surface potential comes closer to that of the conductor and the gradients are smoothed out. This reduces the touch voltage across the entire area, which is what matters in substations and plants with high fault currents.
Where each one appears
- Ring: buildings, installations with moderate fault currents, lightning protection of structures.
- Grid: substations, equipment yards, areas where people operate equipment with high currents.
How to decide
The decision is made on results, not shape: the touch and step voltages are calculated with the proposed configuration and verified to be tolerable. If the ring complies, it is sufficient. If not, cross conductors are added until the grid achieves it. The edge of the grid is the most critical zone for step voltage, and additional conductors or electrodes can be added there.
An example
A small shelter with low-power equipment can be handled with a ring and rods. A transformer yard requires a grid with a verified design. The specific criteria are taken from the guide in force, and design and construction are the responsibility of qualified personnel.