How each one operates
A fuse contains a calibrated element that heats up with current and melts when the accumulated thermal energy, related to the integral of the current squared over time, exceeds a certain value. On melting it interrupts the circuit and must be replaced. A circuit breaker detects overcurrent through a trip device and releases a mechanism that opens its contacts. Once the fault has been cleared, it can be closed again.
Comparison
- Current limiting: current-limiting fuses act so quickly on a severe fault that they cut the current before it reaches its maximum possible value, which reduces thermal and mechanical stresses. Some molded-case breakers also limit current, though to a lesser degree.
- Interrupting capacity: high-rupturing-capacity fuses withstand very high fault currents in a small volume. In a breaker, this capacity is specified according to its construction.
- Resetting: the breaker is reset without changing parts. The fuse requires a suitable replacement, and using the wrong one compromises protection.
- Adjustment: a breaker with an electronic trip unit allows current and times to be adjusted. The fuse has a fixed characteristic.
- Pole operation: in a three-pole breaker, a fault opens all three phases at once. With fuses, just one may melt and leave a three-phase motor running on two phases, with heating; this is why phase-loss protection is commonly added.
- Additional functions: the breaker supports remote tripping, auxiliary contacts, ground-fault protection and metering.
When each one is the better choice
Fuses are preferred where the available fault current is very high, to protect delicate equipment such as starters and drives, or to back up lower-capacity breakers. Breakers are preferred where fast resetting, frequent switching, adjustment or integration with control systems is required.
They can be combined
It is common to use a breaker with upstream current-limiting fuses as backup, or fuses with a disconnect switch. In any case, coordination, selectivity and interrupting capacity are verified against the short-circuit current at that point. Replacement and inspection of these devices are carried out by qualified personnel.