What changes from one to the other
A function generator offers a fixed set of waveforms. An arbitrary generator lets you define the signal point by point and store it in memory, so it can reproduce any shape programmed into it: a real signal captured with an oscilloscope, a simulated mains transient or a pulse train with specific timing. Many current instruments combine both functions.
Parameters that matter in an arbitrary generator
- Sample rate: sets the maximum frequency content the reconstructed signal can contain.
- Vertical resolution: the number of bits in the converter determines the smallest step and the level of quantization noise.
- Memory: limits the length of the waveform or of sequences.
- Reconstruction filter: smooths the steps, but also limits edge speed.
What you see in practice
With a function generator, the frequency changes in fine steps because it comes from phase synthesis. In an arbitrary generator, if the waveform is played back with a fixed clock, not all frequencies are obtained with the same quality, and at certain frequencies there may be jumps or sampling effects. The reconstructed signal is never a perfect copy of the file: the filter and noise modify it.
When a function generator is enough
To stimulate amplifiers, measure frequency response, test filters or generate square clock signals, the standard function does the job with less configuration and less risk of error.
When an arbitrary generator is justified
- A real event must be repeated, such as a voltage dip or a recorded sensor signal.
- A custom modulation or a signal with defined frequency components is required.
- The immunity of a circuit to a specific disturbance is being tested.
Before deciding, define the signal you need and verify that the instrument’s bandwidth and resolution can reproduce it.