The fundamental difference
A dipole consists of two arms fed at the center, each close to a quarter wave long in the case of a half-wave dipole. A monopole is a single quarter-wave arm mounted on a conductive surface. That surface acts as a mirror: by the principle of images, the monopole and its image in the plane form a dipole, but radiation occurs only in the upper half-space.
Design consequences
- Impedance: the radiation resistance of an ideal monopole over an infinite plane is half that of the equivalent dipole.
- Gain: since the energy is emitted into half of space, the gain of a monopole over an ideal plane is higher than that of a dipole, by a theoretical factor of two.
- Ground plane: the monopole depends on it. If the plane is small or absent, the pattern is distorted and the cable or chassis becomes part of the antenna.
- Feed: the dipole is balanced and usually needs a balun. The monopole is fed unbalanced, directly from a coaxial cable, with the shield on the plane.
What the engineer sees in practice
In the upper VHF band or at UHF, a monopole mounted on a vehicle roof or on a metal plate works well. In a small device without a sufficient plane, performance depends on the size of the printed circuit board or the housing. With a dipole, behavior depends less on the surroundings, although nearby objects also have an influence.
How to choose
- If the installation has a large, stable metal surface, the monopole is compact and simple.
- If the antenna must work isolated or without a reference, the dipole is the better choice.
- If vertical space is limited, shortened or loaded versions exist, at the cost of bandwidth and efficiency.
A point to verify
The theoretical figures assume an infinite, perfectly conducting plane. In a real measurement, the finite size of the plane changes the impedance and raises the pattern, so the value must be confirmed with the antenna installed.