The subtraction alternative
A common idea is to connect a passive probe to each point, both with their ground on the circuit common, and ask the oscilloscope for the math function channel 1 minus channel 2. For low-amplitude, low-frequency signals relative to circuit ground, this can work. But it has inherent limitations that a differential probe avoids.
Why subtraction is weak
- Limited common-mode rejection: subtraction only cancels common mode if both channels have exactly the same gain and the same delay. Differences between probes and channels leave a residue that grows with frequency.
- Dynamic range: each channel must accept the full signal, including the large common mode, and the small differential signal ends up represented by only a few converter levels. Resolution is lost exactly where it is needed.
- Noise: the noise of the two channels adds up.
- Reference: both passive probes have their ground at the instrument. If neither of the two points is close to circuit ground, you cannot connect this way without creating a ground current path.
What a differential probe adds
Its input amplifier is designed to ignore common mode with high, factory-adjusted rejection. The differential signal is scaled to a suitable range before it reaches the channel, which makes full use of the resolution. And the circuit under measurement has no ground connection to the instrument, provided the common-mode and differential limits are respected.
An example
Measuring the voltage drop across a sense resistor on the high side of a bridge illustrates the difference. With subtraction, the reading includes the common-mode step from the switching, and part of it appears as false current. With a suitable differential probe, that step is largely rejected. Subtraction is acceptable for a relatively large differential signal, with little common mode, at a low frequency.
How to decide
If the common mode is large, fast or dangerous, use a differential probe with the appropriate rated voltage. Measurements on energized circuits or at hazardous voltages must be made by qualified personnel, following the applicable safety regulations and using accessories with the appropriate category and rated voltage.