The essential trade-off
Contact ensures that the field passes through the sample and not the air, but any imperfection becomes an error. Dispensing with contact removes that problem and the need to prepare the sample, but it introduces other measurement models, more sensitive to geometry and alignment.
Measurement with contact electrodes
- Advantages: high accuracy if the faces are flat and parallel, good sensitivity, widely available equipment.
- Drawbacks: a film of air between electrode and sample falsifies the result, especially in high-permittivity materials; clamping can deform soft materials; applied electrodes add preparation steps.
- Mitigation: metallized or painted electrodes, or the two-measurement method with and without the sample, which compensates for part of the gap effect.
Non-contact measurement
- Advantages: it does not destroy or alter the sample, it is suitable for delicate, soft or hot materials, and it allows large parts to be measured.
- Drawbacks: it requires flat samples large enough that the beam does not diffract at the edges, careful alignment and greater uncertainty; it is used mainly at microwave and higher frequencies.
How to decide
- Frequency: at low frequency almost all methods are contact methods; at very high frequencies free space becomes practical.
- Type of material: soft, hot or brittle tips the choice toward non-contact.
- Required accuracy: if it is critical and the sample can be prepared, well-executed contact usually wins.
- Whether the sample could be damaged or cannot be machined.
What the engineer sees
A poorly prepared contact method gives low, variable values; a poorly aligned non-contact method shows ripples in the result across the band from multiple reflections. Recognizing the symptom helps you know what to correct.
When it does not apply
For liquids and pastes, an immersed probe or a liquid cell solves the contact issue without the problems of solids.