Two different principles
A catalytic sensor measures the heat produced by oxidizing the gas on a heated bead. An infrared sensor sends infrared light through the sample and measures how much is absorbed at the wavelengths characteristic of the gas’s bonds. The first detects a chemical reaction; the second detects an optical property of the molecule.
Comparison
| Aspect | Catalytic | Infrared |
|---|---|---|
| Needs oxygen | Yes | No |
| Works in an inert atmosphere | Not reliably | Yes |
| Poisoning | Vulnerable to silicones, sulfur and halogenated compounds | Not poisoned in that way |
| Hydrogen | Detects it | Does not detect it |
| Hydrocarbons | Detects them, with variable response | Detects them with good selectivity |
| Self-diagnostics | Limited; requires a gas test | Many models detect their own faults |
| Cost | Generally lower | Generally higher |
The differences that settle the choice
Hydrogen
A molecule made up of two identical atoms does not absorb usefully in the infrared. That is why an infrared sensor is no use if the gas of interest is hydrogen. In that case a catalytic sensor or another technology is used.
Oxygen-poor atmospheres
In inerted or low-oxygen tanks, a catalytic sensor underestimates or fails to detect. An infrared sensor keeps measuring, so it is the option when the atmosphere does not contain enough oxygen.
Contaminating environments
Where compounds that damage the catalyst are present, an infrared sensor retains its sensitivity with no silent deterioration.
Fail-safe behavior
A poisoned catalytic sensor can keep showing zero. Many infrared sensors warn of an obstruction or optical fault.
How to decide
- Identify the combustible gas or gases expected.
- If they include hydrogen, the catalytic sensor is the practical option.
- If oxygen may be low or there is a risk of poisoning, prefer infrared.
- Consider maintenance, cost and the availability of calibration gas.
With either type, calibration is done with a reference gas and correction factors are applied. Selection and use must be handled by trained people, in accordance with current regulations.
This guide is for information only. Work involving electrical hazards, heights or hazardous atmospheres must be carried out by qualified, authorized personnel, following the applicable regulations.