The insulating medium changes almost everything
The minimum distance between parts at different voltages depends on the dielectric strength of the medium. Air requires large clearances; a gas such as sulfur hexafluoride, or the alternatives developed to replace it, withstands more voltage over a shorter distance, especially at above-atmospheric pressure. That is why gas-insulated switchgear is smaller.
Air-insulated switchgear
- Live parts exposed to air inside the enclosure, with metal compartments.
- Greater footprint and weight.
- Its dielectric performance depends on the environment: humidity, contamination, dust, altitude and the presence of animals can cause surface discharges.
- The components are visible and can be inspected and repaired with familiar technology.
Gas-insulated switchgear
- Busbars, disconnectors and circuit breakers are housed in sealed vessels, protected from the environment.
- Very compact, useful where space is limited or the environment is aggressive.
- Requires gas density monitoring: a loss reduces the insulating capability.
- The gas must be handled with specific procedures and equipment, and sulfur hexafluoride has a strong greenhouse effect, so its handling and disposal are regulated.
- An internal fault or a major repair may require working on the compartment and recovering the gas.
What the engineer sees in operation
In air-insulated switchgear, deterioration usually shows up as discharge tracks, hot spots at connections or condensation. In gas-insulated switchgear, what is monitored is the density indicator or transmitter, low-pressure alarms and partial discharges measured from the outside, since the live parts cannot be seen.
Selection criteria
| Criterion | Air | Gas |
|---|---|---|
| Available space | Requires more | Very small |
| Environment | Sensitive to contamination | Protected by sealing |
| Maintenance | Direct access to parts | Little, but specialized |
| Gas management | Not applicable | Mandatory |
The choice also depends on the availability of spare parts, trained personnel and the applicable environmental regulations. Any work on medium- or high-voltage switchgear must be done by qualified personnel, with the corresponding safety procedures.