Three strategies, three logics
| Strategy | When to intervene | Basis of the decision |
|---|---|---|
| Corrective | After the failure | The failure is accepted |
| Preventive | By time or usage | The probability of failure is assumed to increase with age |
| Predictive | When a measurement indicates deterioration | The developing failure is detected |
When each one makes sense
- Corrective: for low-cost or redundant equipment, or equipment whose failure has no safety or production consequences; and when there is no way to anticipate the failure.
- Preventive: when wear is proportional to time or usage cycles, as with filters, lubricants or belts. It does not work if failures are random, since replacing a healthy part sometimes introduces early-life failures.
- Predictive: when deterioration is gradual and measurable and the interval between the symptom and the failure allows time to act. It requires instruments, personnel and measurement discipline.
How to choose
- Identify how the equipment fails and whether there is a prior warning signal.
- Assess the consequence: safety, environment, production and cost.
- Compare the cost of the strategy with the cost of the failure.
- Combine: a plant typically uses all three, depending on the asset.
When the answer changes
Equipment that seemed a candidate for corrective maintenance moves to preventive if its shutdown affects safety. And a predictive program that is not fed with data or does not react to alerts is worse than not having one, because it gives a false sense of control. The strategy must be reviewed against the real failure history, not against what was assumed when it was designed.
An example
On a large motor with bearings that degrade gradually, monitoring vibration and temperature makes it possible to schedule the replacement during a convenient shutdown. For an indicator lamp, on the other hand, waiting for the failure and replacing it is the most reasonable course. Between the two extremes, an air filter with a measurable pressure drop is changed according to the differential, not by date.