They do not measure the same thing
The proximity probe measures the relative displacement between its tip and the shaft, that is, what the shaft is doing inside the bearing. The accelerometer attached to the casing measures the absolute acceleration of the casing, which is whatever manages to pass through the oil film, the bearing and the support. If the casing is heavy and stiff, a significant part of the shaft’s motion does not reach the outside.
When the non-contact sensor is the better choice
- Flexible-rotor machines with oil-film bearings, where the shaft has clearance and moves freely.
- When shaft position, orbit, phase or axial position is needed.
- When the aim is to monitor low frequencies and a response down to zero frequency is needed.
When the accelerometer is the better choice
- Machines with rolling-element bearings, where shaft vibration is transmitted to the casing with little attenuation.
- When high frequencies are of interest, such as bearing and gear defects.
- When there is no access for installing probes facing the shaft, or when the installation cost is not justified.
How they complement each other
On critical machines both are installed: the non-contact sensor monitors the rotor and the accelerometer monitors the casing and the high frequencies. The differences between the two readings are a signal in themselves, since they show how shaft vibration is transmitted to the structure.
What to check first
- The machine’s bearing type.
- The frequency band of the expected defect.
- Accessibility and installation cost.
- The evaluation criterion to be applied, which may require one measurement or the other.