One vibration, three descriptions
For sinusoidal motion, the three quantities are linked by frequency: velocity is the derivative of displacement and acceleration is the derivative of velocity. As a result, for a given velocity amplitude, displacement is greater at low frequency and acceleration is greater at high frequency. Choosing the quantity means choosing which part of the spectrum is emphasized.
What each one favors
- Displacement: sensitive to low frequencies. It is relevant when physical movement matters, as with bearing clearances or stresses in a flexible part.
- Velocity: related to vibration energy and fatigue over a wide range of medium frequencies. It is the usual measure for assessing the overall severity of rotating machines.
- Acceleration: related to force. It emphasizes high frequencies, where bearing and gear defects live.
How to decide
- Identify the band in which the phenomenon is expected.
- Verify which sensor covers that band and which quantity it measures directly.
- Check which quantity is required by the evaluation criterion that will be applied.
The sensor determines the conversion: integrating an acceleration signal to obtain velocity or displacement amplifies low-frequency noise, so a displacement integrated from acceleration should not be relied on at very low frequencies.
An example
On a fan with unbalance, the once-per-revolution peak stands out in velocity and in displacement. On the same machine, a bearing with an early defect barely appears in velocity, but does appear in high-frequency acceleration. Looking at only one quantity would have hidden one of the two problems.
When it does not apply
If the band of the problem is not known, it is advisable to record the spectrum in more than one quantity before setting the routine parameter.