Two approaches with different strengths
Manual sampling takes a sample to a laboratory. Online monitoring installs sensors on the transformer that measure continuously. Choosing between them means deciding what information is needed and how quickly.
Comparison
| Aspect | Manual sampling | Online monitoring |
|---|---|---|
| Parameters | Very broad: gases, moisture, acidity, interfacial tension, furans, inhibitor, particles | Limited: one or several gases and sometimes moisture and temperature |
| Accuracy | High, with laboratory calibration and control | Lower and subject to sensor drift |
| Detection speed | Depends on the sampling interval | Continuous; detects rapid changes |
| Sample quality | Sensitive to the sampling and transport procedure | No manual handling |
| Maintenance | Sample logistics | Calibration, verification, and communications |
What an engineer sees in practice
The monitor signals that something has changed and when; the laboratory explains what it is. An online hydrogen alarm is confirmed with a sample and a complete gas profile. Conversely, a stable transformer with regular manual sampling does not need extra sensors.
When online monitoring makes sense
- Critical equipment or equipment that is hard to replace.
- Units with a history of rising gases.
- Remote sites with infrequent visits.
- Highly variable loads that can cause rapidly developing faults.
When manual sampling is enough
For less critical equipment with stable behavior, scheduled sampling with laboratory analysis is usually sufficient and more economical.
How to decide
Start from the criticality, from what you already know about the equipment, and from which faults you want to anticipate. Installing sensors and taking samples on energized equipment must be done by qualified personnel.