The underlying question
There is no absolute winner. The choice depends on the application: fire risk, environment, maintenance experience, and the design constraints of the equipment.
Comparison by criterion
| Criterion | Mineral oil | Natural ester |
|---|---|---|
| Fire safety | Moderate flash and fire points | Much higher points; classified as a lower-risk fluid |
| Moisture | Dissolves little water; moisture soon affects its dielectric strength | Dissolves much more water before saturating; the effect on dielectric strength is smaller |
| Oxidation stability | Better, especially when inhibited | Lower; exposure to air should be limited |
| Viscosity | Lower, better circulation | Higher, with an effect on cooling |
| Origin and environment | Petroleum derivative | Of vegetable origin and more biodegradable |
Other points that carry weight
- Material compatibility: gaskets, paints, and insulation must be compatible with the fluid.
- Diagnosis: the gases and compounds generated by faults differ, so the interpretation criteria for mineral oil do not apply without adaptation.
- Mixtures: fluids must not be mixed without checking compatibility.
- Cost and availability, which vary.
What an engineer sees in practice
At sites with fire risk, such as indoor locations or those close to buildings, ester is usually evaluated from the outset. In networks with a long history and personnel experienced in mineral oil, mineral oil remains the norm.
When the direct comparison does not apply
It is also worth remembering that the fluid does not change the physics of the transformer: heat, moisture, and faults still exist, and what varies is how they show up in the analyses and what safety margin each fluid offers. The fluid in an existing transformer cannot be changed without confirming with the manufacturer that the design, insulation, and gaskets allow it. Any intervention on energized equipment is a matter for qualified personnel.