Central idea
Each type of fault decomposes the oil differently and generates gases in its own proportions. Dividing the concentration of one gas by that of another gives a ratio that, to a large extent, depends not on how much gas was produced or how much has dissolved, but on what kind of process produced it. Ratio methods, such as those of Rogers and Doernenburg or the three-ratio method of IEC 60599, group these ratios into ranges associated with fault types.
Which ratios are commonly used
- Acetylene to ethylene: rises with the energy of the discharge.
- Methane to hydrogen: separates partial discharges from other faults.
- Ethylene to ethane: grows with the temperature of a thermal fault.
How it is applied
- First confirm that there is significant gas generation relative to normal values and to the trend. If not, there is no fault to classify.
- Calculate the ratios from the sample concentrations.
- Locate the result in the table of the chosen method and obtain the probable fault.
- Confirm with the history and with other tests.
What an engineer sees in practice
A diagnosis such as “medium-temperature thermal fault” or “high-energy discharge.” Sometimes the combination does not fall into any range, or a mixed fault appears, and then the method is inconclusive. It should be understood as a statistical guide, not a proof.
When it is not reliable
- With gases close to the detection limit, because the error of the ratio becomes enormous.
- When there has been mixing with gases from an earlier fault or a recent oil treatment.
- In fluids other than mineral oil, where the gas patterns are different.
Decisions about energized equipment must be made by qualified specialists.