What changes between the two
In the continuous test the sample stays in the fog the whole time, with a constant saline film. In the cyclic test, the chamber alternates stages of fog, drying and, frequently, high humidity. That alternation is the central point: outdoors, surfaces get wet, dry and get wet again.
Why drying cycles matter
During drying the salt becomes concentrated and oxygen reaches the surface easily, which changes the corrosion chemistry. Some corrosion products form and transform only with cycling. A coating may stand up well to continuous exposure and perform worse when it goes through repeated wetting and drying, or the reverse.
What each one is for
- Continuous: quality control of coating processes, comparison between lots, verification of defects such as porosity or insufficient thickness. It is simple, and its long history offers a wealth of reference data.
- Cyclic: development and qualification studies that seek a better approximation of in-service behavior, especially in alloys and coating systems sensitive to the moisture sequence.
Limitations
Neither guarantees an equivalence with years of service. The cyclic test comes closer, but even so local factors, such as contaminants, temperature and splashing, differ between applications. Results are better compared with one another and against a reference material than with real time.
How to choose
If the customer or industry specification requires a method, that is the one used. If there is freedom of choice, it is advisable to ask what real environment the product sees and what type of failure is expected: uniform corrosion, pitting, under-paint corrosion, galvanic corrosion. The cyclic test is usually better for the last two.
How to interpret the result
The inspection looks at appearance, mass loss or the spread of corrosion from a scribe. Results are reported using criteria defined before starting, and are accompanied by photographs taken under constant lighting.