The nature of each medium
Fiber guides light inside a dielectric conductor, isolated from the environment. Microwave propagates a wave through free space between antennas, and shares the medium with other signals and with the atmosphere. Almost all the advantages and disadvantages arise from this difference.
Comparison
| Aspect | Fiber optics | Microwave |
|---|---|---|
| Capacity | Very high and expandable with terminal equipment | Limited by the assigned bandwidth |
| Electromagnetic interference | Immune, being dielectric | Susceptible to other signals |
| Effect of weather | None on transmission | Rain and other phenomena attenuate, especially at high frequencies |
| Line of sight | Not required | Essential, with a clear Fresnel zone |
| Deployment | Civil works, rights-of-way permits, cable laying | Antenna installation, sometimes spectrum paperwork |
| Electrical isolation | Galvanically isolates both ends | Also isolates, with no physical conductor |
| Physical security | Tapping it requires access to the cable | The signal propagates through the air |
What decides in practice
- Future capacity required: if large growth is expected, fiber leaves more headroom without changing the medium.
- Terrain and rights of way: a river, a railway or someone else’s land can make cable laying unfeasible or very slow, and that is where microwave wins.
- Required availability: a microwave link is designed with a fade margin. Even so, it will have more variability than fiber.
- Electromagnetic environment: in substations or plants with large fields and strong transients, fiber avoids ground loops and poor isolation.
- Time frame and duration of use: for temporary or backup links, microwave is more agile.
A common approach
Many systems combine both: fiber as the main link and microwave as a backup on an independent physical route, so that a cable cut does not leave the site cut off.