What each one offers
A ferrite adds impedance to the common-mode current passing through the core; it does not act on the differential signal, and its effect depends on the material and on the circuit impedances. It is a corrective component, easy to install on a finished cable.
An input filter is a network of reactive elements (inductors and capacitors) mounted at the point where the cable enters the equipment. It acts on both common mode and differential mode, with attenuation designed for a frequency range, and it can shunt noise to ground with capacitors.
Selection criteria
- Type of noise: if analysis with a current clamp indicates common mode, a ferrite may be enough; if there is strong differential noise, a filter is necessary.
- Size of the problem: a ferrite provides a moderate reduction localized in frequency; a filter can give greater attenuation.
- Project stage: on a prototype or equipment already in the field, a ferrite allows diagnosis and correction without a redesign; during design, the filter is integrated from the start.
- Safety and leakage: the filter’s capacitors to ground add leakage current, which is limited by product safety requirements. A ferrite does not add any.
- Location of the noise: the filter must be where the cable enters the enclosure. If noise couples to the cable inside the enclosure after the filter, the filter is of no use.
When to use both
An input filter reduces noise conducted along the power supply, but a data or motor cable does not pass through it. On those cables, a ferrite complements the treatment. It is also common to add a ferrite to the power cable outside the filter to reduce residual common mode at high frequencies, where filters perform worse because of their parasitic elements.
A case for deciding
If you measure a high common-mode current on a data cable with a clamp and a ferrite reduces it to an acceptable level, nothing more is needed. If the noise is present in the voltage on the power line as measured with a LISN, a ferrite alone is rarely enough and a filter is the answer.