What fundamentally changes
Mineral oil is derived from petroleum. Ester fluids come from vegetable oils (natural ester) or from chemical synthesis (synthetic ester). Both insulate and cool, but their physical and chemical properties differ, and that affects design, operation and diagnostics.
Comparison
| Aspect | Mineral oil | Ester fluid |
|---|---|---|
| Flash point | Lower | Markedly higher |
| Biodegradability | Low | High |
| Moisture | Dissolves little water | Dissolves much more water before saturating |
| Viscosity | Lower | Higher; can affect circulation and cooling |
| Field experience | Very extensive | More recent, growing |
| Cost | Lower | Higher |
Why moisture matters
In the paper-oil system, water migrates between the two according to temperature. An ester can hold more dissolved water, so the paper can retain less moisture at equilibrium. This is associated with a lower rate of paper degradation in the presence of water. It is not a guarantee: water content must still be controlled, and interpretation is done in terms of relative saturation, not the absolute value that would be used with mineral oil.
Practical consequences
- An ester allows equipment to be installed closer to buildings or with fewer fire protection measures, depending on what the standard and the insurer accept.
- When changing from mineral oil to ester in existing equipment, material compatibility, gaskets, viscosity and thermal behavior must be reviewed with the manufacturer.
- Acceptance criteria for mineral oil tests cannot be applied without verifying whether they hold for ester. The same is true of dissolved gas interpretation, which has particular features for ester fluids.
An example
At an indoor substation with fire safety restrictions, an ester is evaluated for its high flash point. Before deciding, it is verified that the transformer design is intended for that fluid and that the laboratory has specific diagnostic criteria.