How they work
In the induction motor, the rotating field of the stator induces currents in the rotor; for this to happen, the rotor turns somewhat slower than the field, that is, with slip. In the synchronous motor, the rotor produces its own field by means of a winding with DC excitation, or with permanent magnets, and locks onto the rotating field of the stator, so it turns at exactly synchronous speed, without slip, as long as it does not lose synchronism.
The differences that matter
- Speed: in the induction motor it varies slightly with load; in the synchronous motor it is constant and fixed by the frequency and the number of poles.
- Power factor: the induction motor always consumes reactive power. The excited synchronous motor can be adjusted to operate at unity or leading power factor and supply reactive power to the system, so it serves as a compensator.
- Starting: the induction motor starts by itself. The wound-rotor synchronous motor needs a damper winding that accelerates it like an induction motor, after which the excitation is applied; permanent magnet motors normally require a drive.
- Construction and maintenance: the squirrel-cage rotor is very rugged and requires almost no maintenance. The synchronous motor has an excitation system, slip rings and brushes, or a brushless exciter, with more components.
- Overload: if the load torque exceeds the synchronous motor’s maximum, it loses synchronism and stops, which calls for specific protection.
Where each one is chosen
The induction motor is the usual choice for the vast majority of pumps, fans, conveyor belts and compressors because of its cost and reliability. The synchronous motor is considered at high power ratings and constant speed, as in compressors or mills, where its efficiency and its reactive power contribution can justify the complexity. Permanent magnet synchronous motors paired with drives are used where high efficiency and precise control are sought.
How to decide
- Define whether the speed must be fixed or variable.
- Evaluate the value of the power factor correction the synchronous motor would provide.
- Compare the complexity of maintenance and starting.
- Consider the supply: starting a large motor affects the voltage.
Detailed specification is done with the manufacturer and the applicable standards. Work on these motors and their excitation systems is done by qualified personnel.