24/7 emergencies 814 777 6921812 230 6079WhatsApp 811 786 0768
Electrónica MonterreyElectrónica MonterreyLaboratorios Creativeit Talk to an engineer
Menu

Direct-On-Line, Wye-Delta or Soft Starter?

The choice between direct-on-line, wye-delta and soft starter depends on how much starting current and torque the supply and the load can tolerate: direct-on-line is simple but abrupt, wye-delta reduces the current with a torque jump, and the soft starter controls it gradually.

Direct-on-line starting

The motor is connected at full voltage. This is the simplest method and delivers maximum starting torque, but the initial current is several times the rated current and the mechanical shock is greater. It is suitable if the supply can tolerate it without significant voltage drops and if the load can withstand the abrupt start.

Wye-delta

This method is used with motors that have all six terminals available and are designed to run in delta at the supply voltage. The motor starts with the windings in wye: each winding receives the line voltage divided by the square root of three. Line current and starting torque are approximately one third of what they would be with a direct delta connection. After a set time, a timer switches to delta.

  • Advantage: reduces starting current with simple equipment.
  • Disadvantage: torque is also reduced, so it only works if the load is light at starting. On switching to delta there is a brief disconnection and a current and torque transient that can be significant if the motor has not accelerated enough.
  • Requires more contactors and wiring.

Soft starter

It increases the voltage continuously with thyristors. It allows the ramp to be adjusted and the current to be limited, and it avoids the switching jump. It costs more than the previous two and generates harmonics during the ramp. It has the same essential restriction: when voltage is reduced, torque falls with the square of the voltage.

How to decide

  1. Know the torque curve of the load during starting. A low-torque load, such as a centrifugal fan or a pump with a closed valve, tolerates reduced voltage; a loaded conveyor belt or a compressor under load does not.
  2. Verify how much voltage drop the system can accept during starting.
  3. Consider the frequency of starts and the mechanical stress on the coupling.
  4. Assess whether speed control will be required at some point; in that case a drive replaces all three.

When each one does not apply

Direct-on-line is not advisable on weak supplies. Wye-delta does not work for heavy starting loads or with motors without the six terminals. The soft starter does not correct a lack of torque. Modifications to starters must be made by qualified personnel.

We do real tests, on video! Watch them on our YouTube channel →

Do you have a problem nobody has been able to measure?

Talk directly to the engineer in charge, with no middlemen.

Talk to an engineer