Criteria that matter
A coaxial connector is a section of transmission line with a discontinuity. Its quality is judged by the match it maintains, the repeatability of its connections, its durability and the frequency range in which a single mode propagates. A smaller diameter allows higher frequencies but is more fragile.
General comparison
| Characteristic | Type N | SMA | Precision |
|---|---|---|---|
| Size | Large | Small | Small or medium, finely machined |
| Ruggedness | High, suitable for outdoor use and frequent handling | Medium, sensitive to excessive torque | Medium, requires care |
| Frequency | RF and microwave applications up to a certain limit | Microwave, up to a higher limit than type N | Designed for the high end of each family |
| Repeatability | Good if kept clean | Moderate; varies widely between manufacturers | The best, with an air dielectric in many designs |
| Typical use | Antennas, equipment cabling, installations | Modules, boards, instruments, prototypes | Calibration, metrology, demanding measurements |
How to choose for the application
- Installation or field use, with frequent handling and environmental exposure: type N is a safe option because of its ruggedness and good protection.
- Compact modules and microwave circuits: SMA offers small size and low cost, at the expense of limited repeatability.
- High-accuracy measurement and calibration: a precision connector is advisable, with fine mechanical tolerances and ports that can be connected many times without degrading.
Compatibility and common errors when mixing
Some precision connectors are mechanically compatible with SMA and can be mated, but the combination damages the precision connector because SMA has wider tolerances. If they are mixed, this is done with adapters designed for the purpose and their use is limited. Other connectors of similar appearance but different dimensions are not compatible, and forcing them destroys them. Always verify compatibility with the manufacturer.
What to check first
- The maximum operating frequency and the margin to the connector limit.
- The number of connections expected during the life of the equipment.
- The power and the environment.
- The availability of calibration kits, cables and adapters of the same type.