What the Q factor represents
The quality factor compares the energy stored in the resonator with the energy it loses in each cycle. A high-Q resonator has low losses and a very narrow resonance. Q is related to bandwidth: the narrower the resonance, the higher the Q.
Loaded Q and unloaded Q
During measurement the resonator is connected to an external circuit through some form of coupling, and that circuit adds losses. The measured factor is the loaded Q, and it is lower than the resonator’s own factor, called the unloaded Q. External losses, those of the resonator itself and radiation losses add up. For this reason, the Q of interest is obtained by correcting the loaded value according to the degree of coupling.
Transmission method
- Couple the resonator to the network analyzer through two ports, with the weakest possible coupling.
- Measure transmission as a function of frequency and locate the resonance peak.
- Determine the bandwidth between the points at which the power falls to half of the peak, equivalent to three decibels below it.
- Calculate the loaded Q as the center frequency divided by that bandwidth.
- Obtain the unloaded Q from the insertion loss at the peak. With symmetrical coupling, the unloaded Q is the loaded Q divided by one minus the linear amplitude ratio at the peak. If the coupling is very weak, the two values are almost equal.
Reflection method
This is measured through a single port. The reflection curve is fitted to a model, or the circle traced by the resonance on the Smith chart is used, to extract the resonant frequency, the Q and the coupling coefficient at the same time. It is useful for one-port resonators.
Other options
For very high-Q resonators, frequency-domain measurement requires very fine resolution; in that case the decay time of the energy after a pulse is measured, which is inversely proportional to the losses.
Errors to avoid
- Excessively strong coupling, which loads the resonator and lowers the measured Q.
- Insufficient frequency resolution, with few points on the peak.
- Thermal drift during the sweep, because the resonant frequency changes with temperature.
- An instrument measurement bandwidth comparable to that of the resonance.
- Parasitic resonances from cables or supports close to the one being measured.