The fundamental difference
At low voltage, insulation behaves almost like a linear resistance and the measurement mainly reflects overall conduction and surface leakage. At high voltage, field-dependent phenomena appear: non-linear conduction, ionization in voids, field concentration at defects and, ultimately, breakdown. Each test answers different questions.
Comparison
| Aspect | Low voltage | High voltage |
|---|---|---|
| Stress on the insulation | Much lower than in service | Similar to or higher than in service |
| What it detects best | Moisture, contamination, advanced deterioration | Local defects, voids, field-dependent weaknesses |
| Risk of damage | Very low | Real, especially in aged insulation |
| Expected behavior | Almost constant resistance | Non-linearity and discharges may appear |
| Equipment required | Portable and simple | More complex, with stricter safety measures |
What each one contributes
- Low voltage: suitable as a routine check and for trending. A low value points to a problem; a high value does not guarantee that the insulation will withstand the service voltage during an overvoltage.
- High voltage: makes it possible to verify that the insulation withstands a defined stress level or to compare the resistance at different steps. Withstand voltage and partial discharge tests fall into this category.
How to choose
- Start from the rated voltage of the equipment and the recommendations of the manufacturer and applicable standards.
- Begin with the gentler test. If it gives a poor value, it is probably not advisable to apply a higher voltage.
- Move on to higher-voltage tests when the aim is to detect weaknesses or validate a repair and the insulation is in a condition to withstand them.
- Keep the same type of test over time so that trends remain comparable.
When high voltage does not apply
It is not recommended on equipment that is badly aged or damp, or that has electronic components unable to tolerate the test level, unless they are disconnected first. A high-voltage test is potentially destructive.
Safety
Both tests, and high-voltage tests in particular, must be performed by qualified persons in accordance with applicable regulations, and the equipment must be discharged and grounded when finished.