What a solder joint is and why it is the weak link
Solder is both the electrical connection and the mechanical support of the component. A thin intermetallic layer forms between the alloy and the copper of the trace; that layer is hard and brittle, while the rest of the alloy is relatively soft. Because the component, the board and the alloy expand at different rates, the joint absorbs the difference by deforming slightly in each cycle.
Main mechanisms
- Thermal fatigue: each power on/off cycle, or each swing in ambient temperature, deforms the joint because of the difference in expansion coefficients. After many cycles a crack appears and grows from the edge until it severs the connection.
- Mechanical stress: board flexing during screw fastening, vibration, impacts or connectors inserted with force. Heavy or tall components concentrate the stress at their leads.
- Manufacturing defects: poor wetting due to oxidation or contamination, an unsuitable temperature profile, voids or an insufficient amount of alloy. These produce joints that look correct but have little effective area.
- Intermetallic brittleness: an intermetallic layer that is too thick, caused by excessive time or temperature or by prolonged aging at high temperature, fractures in a brittle manner on impact.
- Corrosion and contamination: flux residues or moisture attack the joint and the trace.
What an engineer sees in practice
The typical symptom is an intermittent fault that changes when the board is pressed, bent or heated, or that appears only with temperature or vibration. Under magnification, a fatigue crack appears as a fine line at the edge of the joint, and a poorly wetted joint has a dull, grainy surface and a high contact angle with the pad. When separation is complete, the surface of the pad or lead is left smooth with no alloy adhering to it, a sign that a good joint never formed.
How to tell the causes apart
- Check whether the joints fail on heavy components, at board edges or near screws: this points to mechanical stress.
- Look for failures on components in low-flexibility packages, such as those with hidden terminations: this points to thermal fatigue.
- Observe whether the defect repeats in the same lot or position: this points to the manufacturing process.
- Confirm with a metallographic cross-section when certainty is required, to see cracks, voids and intermetallic thickness.
An example
An edge connector that fails only when the cable is inserted usually shows cracks in the leads on one side only: the leverage of the cable concentrates the stress there. Reflowing the joint may restore continuity, but if the mechanical support is not resolved, the failure returns.