What each environment contributes
On site, the equipment works with its real load, power supply, environment and connections. In the laboratory, instruments, test benches, tools and a controlled environment are available where the equipment can be disassembled and measurements repeated.
When on site is better
- The failure depends on site conditions: load, power quality, vibration, temperature, humidity or interaction with other equipment.
- The equipment is very large, is integrated into a process, or moving it involves risk or a prolonged shutdown.
- The failure is intermittent and only appears in operation, so recording during operation is needed.
- You want to confirm whether the problem is in the equipment or in the installation.
When the laboratory is better
- The diagnosis requires disassembly, precise measurement or instruments that are not portable.
- The equipment needs to be isolated from its environment to find out whether the failure is its own.
- You want to reproduce the failure under controlled conditions, such as temperature or voltage variations.
- Evidence must be preserved and documented in detail.
The misleading case
Equipment that fails at the plant and passes all the tests on the bench is not necessarily good: the cause may be in the installation, in the load or in a condition the bench does not reproduce. Conversely, a failure that disappears when the equipment is taken out of its environment points to the environment.
A combined approach
Often an on-site inspection is done first to collect operating data and rule out external causes, followed by detailed analysis in the laboratory. The data from both stages are then compared.
On-site work on energized installations must be carried out by qualified personnel in accordance with applicable regulations.